Tips for Building Strong Relationships with Journalists and Influencers!

MUSKLY-Public-Relations-Content-Marketing

 

 

Building strong relationships with journalists and influencers is crucial for effective communication in today’s media landscape. This article presents expert-backed strategies to help you establish meaningful connections with key media figures. From offering valuable insights to cultivating genuine rapport, these tips will guide you in creating mutually beneficial partnerships that can amplify your message and enhance your professional network.

 

  • Lead with Value Before Asking
  • Prioritize Relevance and Quality
  • Network Before Pitching
  • Offer Thoughtful and Timely Insights
  • Build Trust Through Consistent Engagement
  • Treat Outreach as a Partnership
  • Provide Exclusive Data and Expert Commentary
  • Send Something Useful First
  • Position Yourself as an Industry Expert
  • Co-Create Content as Creative Partners
  • Cultivate Genuine Rapport Over Time
  • Solve Their Editorial Puzzle
  • Research and Offer Relevant Value
  • Share Authentic Challenges and Lessons
  • Engage Before Pitching to Prove Attentiveness

 

Lead with Value Before Asking

 

Everyone wants coverage — but most people treat journalists like vending machines.

 

They fire off generic pitches and expect instant exposure. That’s not how relationships work.

 

Here’s my #1 tip for building strong, lasting connections with journalists or influencers: Lead with value — before you ever ask for anything.

 

We once launched a regional campaign for a property client. We needed local press to cover the launch. So we reached out to three journalists we’d never worked with.

 

At first, nothing. Zero replies. So I switched it up.

 

Instead of pitching a story, I emailed one journalist with this subject line: “Saw your piece on Green Belt housing — mind if I share a stat?”

 

In the body, I added:

 

“Loved your recent article on housing in rural towns. We’ve seen a 43% spike in planning application requests in South Ayrshire — thought it might add weight to your future pieces.”

 

That was it. No, ask. Just context they could use.

 

She replied in under an hour. Asked for a follow-up. We gave her a full dataset. She used it in a later article and then came back to us asking for a quote on a follow-up piece.

 

That’s how the relationship started.

 

We did the same with influencers: Commented on 3-5 of their posts without pushing our brand. Shared their stuff with our audience. Offered assets they could reuse. Only later did we pitch collaborations.

 

What made it effective?

 

Respect their world. Read their work. Get their beat. Know what they care about. Give before you ask. Offer an insight, angle, stat, or story that makes their job easier. Be human. Drop the PR speak. Lead with appreciation and relevance.

 

Over time, that approach paid off.

 

Now, when we launch new projects, we have a list of journalists and creators who want to hear from us — because we’ve earned the right to their attention.

 

So don’t just pitch. Build rapport like you would with a friend: Be helpful. Be consistent. Show up before you’re needed.

 

And when the time comes, your story won’t feel like a pitch — it’ll feel like a natural extension of a real relationship.

 

Nicholas Robb, UK Design agency, Design Hero

 

Prioritize Relevance and Quality

 

You must focus on relevance and quality above all else.

 

You can easily destroy relationships with poor-quality responses and content, so you need to focus on what is right for the journalist and provide quality to the level where whatever you’re sending is something they can readily use.

 

Tracey Beveridge, HR Director, Personnel Checks

 

Network Before Pitching

 

The best relationships I’ve built with journalists started before I needed something. I try to treat it like networking, not pitching. I follow them, read what they write, and respond thoughtfully when something resonates, not only with a “great article” comment but with a response that shows I read it. It’s simple, but it builds familiarity without any pressure.

 

When I do reach out, I keep it short and useful. If I can offer a unique take or a credible quote that fits their beat, I send it with no fluff, just clear value. And if they pass? No hard feelings and I keep the door open. This mindset has helped me build real, ongoing connections with people who know I’m not just showing up when I need coverage.

 

Matias Rodsevich, Founder & CEO, PRLab

 

Offer Thoughtful and Timely Insights

 

My top tip for building strong relationships with journalists and influencers is simple: do your homework and offer value before you pitch. I never send a cold email without first reading their recent work or understanding their audience. When I reference something specific they’ve written, it shows I respect their time and perspective.

 

For example, I once connected with a lifestyle writer by referencing her article on burnout. I linked it to a client’s new wellness tool, and because the pitch was thoughtful and relevant, she responded positively, and we secured coverage. But remember, consistency also matters. I use platforms like Muck Rack to track preferences and use social media to casually engage, retweeting, commenting, or sharing their work. These touchpoints build familiarity over time, so when I do reach out, I’m not a stranger.

 

One memorable example came from an influencer in the wellness space. After months of following and engaging with her posts, I pitched a brand partnership. She immediately replied, saying she appreciated the genuine engagement and that our brand felt like a natural fit. When possible, I go out of my way to help without expecting anything. If I come across a good source or topic that fits their beat, even if it’s unrelated to my client, I’ll send it over. That kind of goodwill builds long-term rapport.

 

In the end, treating journalists and influencers as collaborators, not just channels, makes the difference. Trust, relevance, and consistency are the foundation of every successful media relationship I’ve built.

 

Rita Zhang, Marketing Coordinator, Achievable

 

Build Trust Through Consistent Engagement

 

Be consistent and useful before you ever ask for anything. Most journalists and influencers deal with recycled pitches and templated outreach every day. If you show up with information that’s timely, clear, and relevant to your audience, you immediately stand out. I start by following their work, sharing it with context, and commenting when they post. That early engagement shows I’m not just showing up for my own gain.

 

Then I make the first outreach short, specific and aligned with what they care about. One example is a tech reporter I contacted after he covered mobile sustainability. I sent him a brief note pointing to new trends in device recycling, with one relevant data point from our platform. No pitch. Just useful insight. When I followed up later with a story angle, he already knew who I was.

 

These relationships build on trust over time. If you respect their deadlines, send complete assets, and never waste their time, they’ll come back. It’s about being someone they want in their inbox. I keep a short list of contacts I update monthly with relevant data, not just announcements. That level of discipline has kept our brand visible without chasing headlines.

 

Alec Loeb, VP of Growth Marketing, EcoATM

 

Treat Outreach as a Partnership

 

In my perspective, too many people approach media as if they’re placing an order: “Here’s my news, now run it.” 

 

But the journalists I’ve built lasting trust with are the ones I took the time to listen to first. That means reading what they write, understanding the tone they use, and respecting the kinds of stories they actually care about. If you want to stand out in a crowded inbox, stop selling and start supporting. Offer a fresh angle. Make their job easier. And most importantly, follow through. If you say you’ll deliver a quote or connect them with a source, do it fast and do it right. 

 

That kind of reliability is rare, and in my experience, it’s what turns one-time pitches into long-term media relationships. Remember, you don’t need a big headline to build rapport. You just need to show you’re not wasting their time.

 

Jeff Mains, Founder and CEO, Champion Leadership Group

 

Provide Exclusive Data and Expert Commentary

 

Building authentic connections with journalists starts with genuine value exchange. We focus on understanding their beat deeply before making contact. Research their recent articles, identify knowledge gaps in their coverage, and approach them with specific insights that directly address those gaps. Skip generic pitches entirely. Instead, offer exclusive data points, expert commentary on breaking news in their sector, or access to hard-to-reach sources. This positions you as a valuable resource rather than another person seeking coverage.

 

Timing and consistency matter more than frequency. We respond quickly when journalists post requests for sources or expertise on social platforms. Speed often determines who gets quoted. Build rapport through small interactions first — share their articles with thoughtful commentary, provide brief expert takes on trending topics in their field, or connect them with other credible sources when appropriate. These micro-engagements create familiarity before you need coverage. Maintain regular but non-intrusive contact by sharing relevant industry developments or offering seasonal story angles. The goal is to become their go-to expert in your field through consistent value delivery rather than aggressive outreach.

 

Thulazshini Tamilchelvan, Content Workflow Coordinator, Team Lead, Ampifire

 

Send Something Useful First

 

My top move is ridiculously simple: send something useful before asking for anything in return. Skip the copy-paste press kit. Scan what a journalist or influencer is actually talking about that week, then send a punchy line, a statistic, or even a quick $10 gift card for coffee if you really want to be memorable.

 

The trick is to show you pay attention, even if it takes five minutes to read their last three articles or scan their top posts. The fact is, nobody remembers the person who just asks for free publicity; they remember the one who makes their life easier.

 

Kiara DeWitt, RN, CPN, Founder & CEO, Injectco

 

Position Yourself as an Industry Expert

 

My #1 recommendation for people aiming to build strong relationships with journalists and influencers is to put yourself in their shoes and identify what kind of communications they’re likely to respond positively to. Most journalists and influencers receive lots of self-serving pitches from businesses that want publicity and attention. If you can reach out to them to offer value to them, rather than to yourself, they’re much more likely to respond to you and create the opportunity to build a relationship.

 

I’ve found that reaching out to offer expertise works really well. Journalists are constantly looking for reliable subject matter experts to act as sources of authority for their stories. If you know your industry better than others, or if you have a specific skill that’s relevant at the moment, let them know about it and offer valuable insight that can help them publish something of interest to their audience. Often, a single quote or collaboration on one article can lead to a long-term professional relationship and even referrals within their network.

 

Hershel Glueck, CEO, Hero Time

 

Co-Create Content as Creative Partners

 

Think of them as your creative partners rather than simply coverage subjects.

 

When you bring a journalist or influencer behind the scenes to actually lay a tile pattern or try a custom finish themselves, you’re co-creating content that feels natural and offers them genuine insight, rather than spoon-feeding a press release.

 

Start with a micro-move that demonstrates that you’ve done your homework and know their style.

 

Send a personalized mini-kit: maybe a tiny sample piece of reclaimed wood with a mood-board style note telling them why you chose that grain according to their past feature on rustic interiors. This tactile, mindful strategy cuts through the noise of an inbox and shows you respect their point of view.

 

Mark Lumpkin, Sales Director in Renovation & Design, STR Cribs

 

Cultivate Genuine Rapport Over Time

 

My top tip is to actually give value before you ask for anything. Don’t just pitch your story out of the blue like everyone else. Take the time to follow their work, share their content, and leave thoughtful comments or feedback. If you approach them, reference something they’ve published recently so it doesn’t feel like a cold pitch.

 

When you finally reach out, keep it short and personal. Show them you’re a real person and not just looking for a backlink or a favor. Building real rapport takes a bit more time upfront, but it makes a huge difference. Most people skip this step and wonder why they never get a reply.

 

Raphael Larouche, Founder & SEO Specialist, seomontreal.io

 

Solve Their Editorial Puzzle

 

We treat every media relationship like a high-stakes legal case: we research their past work, understand their beat, and offer story-enhancing insights that cut through the noise. The truth is press releases are dead. A quick, personalized message that solves their editorial puzzle is what earns a callback.

 

Here’s the stat that shifted our entire PR approach: 61% of journalists say the biggest turnoff is receiving irrelevant pitches. We leaned into that hard, which is why our legal marketing clients are consistently featured across top-tier publications. Speak their language, make their life easier, and ditch the buzzwords. The best rapport isn’t built with compliments; it’s built with context.

 

Shamil Shamilov, CEO, dNOVO Group

 

Research and Offer Relevant Value

 

The #1 tip I give to people interested in developing relationships with journalists and influencers is to offer value before asking for anything. Journalists and influencers are constantly pitched with various products, stories, and offers, usually by PR representatives who spend little to no time getting to know them. If you can research their work, reference it genuinely, and reach out with something that’s relevant to them, like an exclusive piece of data, expert commentary, or a story angle that matches their focus, there’s a good chance they’ll respond to you, especially if your pitch is concise and helpful. From there, consistency and respect build real rapport over time, giving you a promotional channel and the journalist or influencer a source they can rely on to give them important news and insights.

 

Assaf Sternberg, Founder & CEO, Tiroflx

 

Share Authentic Challenges and Lessons

 

Most people approach journalists and influencers as if they’re selling something. They lead with achievements, credentials, and polished success stories. I’ve found the opposite approach works far better. When I reach out, I share a specific failure or challenge I’ve faced that relates to their beat. It’s not a humble brag disguised as vulnerability, but a real mistake with real consequences.

 

This approach works because journalists are inundated with perfect narratives. They need authentic stories with tension and resolution. When you lead with what went wrong and what you learned, you’re providing them with the conflict their story needs. Additionally, you’re demonstrating that you understand their job isn’t to be your PR department. Build the relationship on being a useful source who understands storytelling, not just another person asking for coverage. The rapport follows naturally when you’re genuinely helpful rather than transactional.

 

Maria Matarelli, CEO, Formula Ink

 

Engage Before Pitching to Prove Attentiveness

 

The best media relationships don’t start with a pitch — they start with proof you’ve been listening.

 

One of our go-to tactics is engaging with a journalist’s or influencer’s work before we ever reach out — commenting thoughtfully, sharing their content, or referencing a recent piece in our first message. When we finally pitch, it’s not cold — it’s contextual. The key is to treat them like collaborators, not megaphones.

 

The strongest PR wins we’ve had have come from relationships built on respect, relevance, and real value.

 

David Quintero, CEO and Marketing Expert, NewswireJet


Md Nazrul Islam (aka SocialMusker) is the founder of MUSKLY, an award-winning Content Marketing & SEO-centric DigitalPR company focused on SaaS tech. He helps businesses increase conversion rates, close more sales, and get positive ROI from Content Marketing & organic SEO strategies.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *